POLL/PROPOSAL: Kill the "Music", "Film"

Jack · Post by **Jack** » Wed May 21, 2003 3:56 pm

Since almost no one at all ever uses the Music, Film, and Kitchen forums, why not get rid of them and let people discuss those in General? I really think it would make sense, and would definitely encourage more good conversation.

creapyrob · Post by **creapyrob** » Wed May 21, 2003 4:00 pm

They aren't hurting anything are they?

Hardcoregirl · Post by **Hardcoregirl** » Wed May 21, 2003 4:05 pm

Well, general, the dumpster and gothquiz seem to be the most popular..but those other forums aren't hurting anything. And when we do want to discuss those things...we have a place for them.

forum nazi. :wink:

Jack · Post by **Jack** » Wed May 21, 2003 4:08 pm

Dude, I am so not being a Forum Nazi. I'm just suggestin' something that would make the General forum more interesting. Why isn't discussion of music on-topic for a "Gothic" website, since music an huge part of the Gothic subculture? I'm just saying, for people who don't have time to check every single forum, it would be a lot easier. Dontcha think?

Hardcoregirl · Post by **Hardcoregirl** » Wed May 21, 2003 4:16 pm

Well, if you hit "posts since last visit" on your upper right corner...it will pull up all the new threads or threads that have been posted to...and you can choose what you wanna read.

The Fallen · Post by **The Fallen** » Wed May 21, 2003 4:16 pm

Some peoples interests vary, its not like I really love to talk about music, since I have my own peculiar tastes. To each his own. I say let em stay. Hell I check em whenever they're lit up, sometimes I might even throw in my 2¢.

Caustic · Post by **Caustic** » Wed May 21, 2003 4:17 pm

Even I'm voting for disintegration.

Jack · Post by **Jack** » Wed May 21, 2003 4:25 pm

The Fallen wrote:Some peoples interests vary, its not like I really love to talk about music, since I have my own peculiar tastes. To each his own.

See, you're just proving my point for me, here. There's a lot of stuff talked about in General that I don't care for, but I don't think it all needs separate forums.

Regardless of the "Film" and "Kitchen" forums - there really is just no point to having a separate music forum. We all listen to music. We all dance to it, we all have favorite bands, proper music selection is apparently the very most important thing at Goth Nights, so simply explain to me why discussion of music, done politely, isn't on-topic for a "General" forum?

I mean, hey, why isn't the "Sanctus Request" thread posted in the Music forum, if music is supposed to stay there?

Let me be clear - I totally agree that, if the General forum was really busy and had tons of posts being made every day, and the Music forum was ever used (go look - there are like 6 total posts in the whole thing) - if both things things were true, I wouldn't have suggested this at all.

But given:

A) The General forum is not overflowing with posts, and

B) The Music forum is almost entirely unused,

doesn't seem like it would improve the board to merge them, at least until so much music talk broke out that the forum needed to be re-instated?

The Stormstress · Post by **The Stormstress** » Wed May 21, 2003 4:43 pm

I'm still not over hearing that Astrology belongs n the GothGeek Forum... & still don't think it does. As 4 those other forums mentioned, I say lose 'em if u need 2 clean out the space... Otherwise, it doesn't seem 2 matter.

celticsmith · Post by **celticsmith** » Wed May 21, 2003 5:58 pm

Why clutter up the General any more than it already is.

Extra rooms are useful if only for storage to find what you are looking for when looking for somthing more specific.

Like recipies, restaurant reviews, in the kitchen
Band and venue reviews in music (like I just posted today)

Ever try to find somthing old in the General room?....Nigh unto impossible if it is not being currently discussed.

Also, once a thread falls off the first page it just sinks deeper and deeper into the General Abyss

.......and perhaps not EVERYONE uses the other rooms but some people do.

Kinda like the bathrooms at Fairbanks, not everone uses them, and some people use them for purposes for which they were not intended......(I mean like being able to talk without shouting.....and other stuff)

But boy you sure would miss-em if they were gone!

iblis · Post by **iblis** » Wed May 21, 2003 7:22 pm

I think that the forums should stay, however I'd love to see some people posting more drink recipes in the Kitchen forum. :mrgreen:

Jack · Post by **Jack** » Wed May 21, 2003 7:24 pm

celticsmith wrote:Why clutter up the General any more than it already is.

But that's what I'm saying - the General forum isn't all cluttered up. As far as message boards go, our General forum is pretty darn slow-moving. I would bet you $1.80 that allowing music talk in the General forum would not significantly harm anything in any way whatsoever, and in fact, would help the General forum because it would stimulate more and more diverse conversation.

I see the General forum as the online social hangout, much like 11th Street. Now, when you guys go to 11th Street, do you decide whether you want to sit at the General Table, the Music Table, the Film Table, or the Dumpster table?

iblis · Post by **iblis** » Wed May 21, 2003 7:40 pm

Jack wrote:I see the General forum as the online social hangout, much like 11th Street. Now, when you guys go to 11th Street, do you decide whether you want to sit at the General Table, the Music Table, the Film Table, or the Dumpster table?

I have it on good authority that any table I sit down at becomes the Dumpster table.

Post by **darkvader** » Wed May 21, 2003 8:07 pm

Jack wrote:Since almost no one at all ever uses the Music, Film, and Kitchen forums, why not get rid of them and let people discuss those in General? I really think it would make sense, and would definitely encourage more good conversation.

Those forums serve specific purposes. They are not really discussion forums, they are review forums.

Music discussion should take place in General. Music reviews should be posted to the Music and Bands forum.

The Kitchen's primary purpose is for posting recipies.

These things are all the sort of thing that should be accessable for reference use, and merging them into General would make it far more difficult to use them as reference sources.

Post by **darkvader** » Wed May 21, 2003 8:08 pm

The Stormstress wrote:I'm still not over hearing that Astrology belongs n the GothGeek Forum... & still don't think it does. As 4 those other forums mentioned, I say lose 'em if u need 2 clean out the space... Otherwise, it doesn't seem 2 matter.

Astrology does not belong in GothGeek.

I don't need to clean out the space.

junkie christ · Post by **junkie christ** » Wed May 21, 2003 9:57 pm

lets just use em more

labluegirl · Post by **labluegirl** » Wed May 21, 2003 9:58 pm

i'll have to agree with jack (and not just because he's jack)

it does seem that the general forum is a lot slower since it's been switched to the new format. probably because of the chat...but it would be nice not to have to look through all the other forums to find music talk or whatnot. it seems to be the trend these days for any forum to have ten million subsections, and it's a bit overwhelming if you don't have a lot of time to look through everything. besides, with the small number of posts those subsections get, it's not like it would add so much more post volume to general. but, for now, buttercup brings up a good point with the 'posts since last visit' advice. ohwell.

celticsmith · Post by **celticsmith** » Wed May 21, 2003 10:40 pm

iblis wrote:I think that the forums should stay, however I'd love to see some people posting more drink recipes in the Kitchen forum.

I'll see what I can do to fer yah.

celticsmith · Post by **celticsmith** » Wed May 21, 2003 10:49 pm

labluegirl wrote:i'll have to agree with jack (and not just because he's jack)

it does seem that the general forum is a lot slower since it's been switched to the new format. probably because of the chat...but it would be nice not to have to look through all the other forums to find music talk or whatnot. it seems to be the trend these days for any forum to have ten million subsections, and it's a bit overwhelming if you don't have a lot of time to look through everything. besides, with the small number of posts those subsections get, it's not like it would add so much more post volume to general. but, for now, buttercup brings up a good point with the 'posts since last visit' advice. ohwell.

You do bring up a good point about though....the chat is one of the more significant reasons for the traffic being slower in General.

I participate in three forums now (Nashville, Knoxville and Fetish) and all three have chats and much of the fluffyer conversations (like DIV's rock talk) tend to disappear into the aether there.

Jack · Post by **Jack** » Thu May 22, 2003 4:16 pm

DarkVader wrote:Music discussion should take place in General.

OK. Then why was my "What 5 Albums are you listening to?" thread moved to the Music Review section?

And who added the option to my poll that says "Who Cares?" Do we not own our own posts anymore?

Your resident badguy,
JESUS CHRIST

POLL/PROPOSAL: Kill the "Music", "Film"

Should the Music, Film and Kitchen Forums get axed?

POLL/PROPOSAL: Kill the "Music", "Film"

Re: POLL/PROPOSAL: Kill the "Music", "Film&qu

Re: POLL/PROPOSAL: Kill the "Music", "Film&am